Maine PointeResults. Now.™

Why your S&OP meeting stopped making decisions

Most companies have an S&OP meeting. Far fewer have an S&OP decision.

Brad Stitt · Senior Advisor, Integrated Business Planning & AI-Enabled Supply Chain TransformationLinkedIn profile ↗
5 min read

Most companies have an S&OP meeting. Far fewer have an S&OP decision.

You can tell the difference in the first ten minutes. If the room spends most of the hour explaining why last month's numbers came out the way they did, you're in a status meeting. Decisions about next quarter, such as whether to take the order, add the shift or build the inventory, still get made later, by email and escalation, by whoever shouts loudest.

How it drifts

It almost never starts that way. Usually the process was designed well, then slowly hollowed out:

  • The chair stopped coming. Once the CEO or GM delegates the meeting, it loses the authority to settle trade-offs between sales, operations and finance.
  • The pre-work became the meeting. Demand and supply reviews that should arrive finished get re-litigated in the executive session.
  • Nobody owns the number. When sales doesn't own the demand plan, the plant builds to its own forecast. One specialty chemicals business we worked with was building to “phantom demand” for exactly this reason, and had more than 2,000 tonnes of legacy inventory to show for it.
  • Options never arrive. The room is shown a gap but not two or three priced ways to close it, so there's nothing to choose between.

What a decision meeting looks like

  • A chair with authority who closes every trade-off before the meeting ends.
  • One reconciled plan coming in, with gaps already priced in service, inventory, margin and cash.
  • Options, not reports. Each gap arrives with two or three alternatives and a recommendation.
  • Named owners and dates going out, so actions are tracked before the next cycle.

The meeting gets shorter and the agenda looks forward. Most of the content should be about the next three to eighteen months, not the last one.

Where AI helps, and where it doesn't

AI can build the meeting pack, flag forecast bias by product and contributor, and run what-if scenarios live in the room instead of over a week of spreadsheet work. It can't decide for you. The point is to give leadership better evidence, faster, so the hour is spent deciding.

The test

At the end of your next S&OP meeting, count the decisions made, with owners. If the answer is zero, the process isn't broken. It has just turned into a report. That's fixable, and usually faster than people expect: when that chemicals business redesigned S&OP with real sales ownership, it cleared 530 tonnes of legacy inventory in three months.

Start with an Integrated Planning Assessment: a baseline on your data, a review of how the cycle really runs, the value sized in cash and EBITDA, and a roadmap your leadership can approve.

Brad Stitt, Senior Advisor, Integrated Business Planning & AI-Enabled Supply Chain Transformation
Author
Brad Stitt
Senior Advisor, Integrated Business Planning & AI-Enabled Supply Chain Transformation — Maine Pointe
LinkedIn profile ↗
Talk to our team →

Facing this in your business?

Tell us what you're trying to fix. A partner who has done it before will come back to you.

Talk to a partner