Maine PointeResults. Now.™

How to choose a supply chain consulting firm: 8 questions to ask

Most firms look the same on paper. These questions separate the ones that put results on your P&L from the ones that leave you a report.

Joseph Esteves · Chief Executive Officer
6 min read

A supply chain consulting firm helps a business improve how it plans, buys, makes, moves and delivers, so it can grow, serve customers and generate cash at lower cost. The hard part isn't finding one. It's telling apart the firms that deliver measurable results from the ones that deliver slides.

Use these eight questions in your first conversations. A good firm will welcome all of them.

1. Will you show me the value before we sign?

Ask for an assessment on your own data, not a generic benchmark. You should see where the value is, roughly how much, and how long it takes to reach the P&L before committing to a full program.

2. How do you measure results, and who signs them off?

Results should be agreed with your finance team, measured against a baseline both sides accept, and reported in EBITDA and cash. If the firm measures its own success, be careful.

3. Do you implement, or only recommend?

Strategy without execution is the most common reason consulting programs disappoint. Ask who will be on the plant floor, in supplier negotiations and in the planning meeting, and for how long.

4. Can you work end to end?

Fixing procurement while ignoring inventory, or cutting logistics cost while hurting service, moves the problem rather than solving it. Look for a firm that can connect plan, buy, make, move and fulfill, even if you start in one area.

5. Who exactly will do the work?

  • Meet the people who will be on site, not only the partner who sells the work.
  • Ask how many of them have run operations or supply chains themselves.
  • Ask how often the team changes during a program.

6. Show me a result like mine

Ask for case studies in your industry and at your scale, with named outcomes. For example, one automotive supplier we worked with recorded $8.7M of P&L impact and a 25% improvement in schedule attainment. Specific numbers tied to a specific situation are worth more than averages.

7. How do you use AI and data?

Good answers are concrete: which decisions AI will support, which data it needs, and how your people stay in control. Be wary of AI that arrives as a separate project with no line to the P&L.

8. What stays behind when you leave?

The value should keep growing after the consultants go. Ask what tools, routines and skills your team keeps, and how results will be tracked once the engagement ends.

A simple scorecard

  • Value shown on your data before you commit
  • Results agreed with finance, in EBITDA and cash
  • Implementation, not just recommendations
  • End-to-end view across plan, buy, make, move and fulfill
  • Experienced operators on site
  • Relevant, specific proof
  • Practical AI tied to decisions
  • Capability and tracking left behind
Joseph Esteves, Chief Executive Officer
Author
Joseph Esteves
Chief Executive Officer — Maine Pointe
Talk to our team →

Facing this in your business?

Tell us what you're trying to fix. A partner who has done it before will come back to you.

Talk to a partner