Maine PointeResults. Now.™

Who Really Owns Value Creation Now? The Shift from Deal Partners to Operating Teams

For most of private equity's history, the answer to "who owns the result?" was simple.

David Jadwin · Managing Director, Head of Private CapitalLinkedIn profile ↗
5 min read

For most of private equity's history, the answer to "who owns the result?" was simple. The deal partner found the company, built the thesis, sat on the board, and lived with the outcome.

That's no longer how it works. Ownership of the result now sits across an operating team, functional specialists, outside advisors, and, increasingly, a vendor-management function that decides which advisors get hired. The industry hasn't fully reckoned with what that means for how much EBITDA a deal actually captures.

The operating team has taken the wheel

In its Global Private Markets Report 2026, McKinsey found that firms have more than doubled the size of their operating groups on average since 2021. Engagement with portfolio companies grew fastest in IT and technology infrastructure (up 13 points), procurement and supply chain (up nine), and digital and AI (up nine). And 60% of respondents now use operating group members to quantify bankable improvements during diligence.

McKinsey's framing is blunt: "Operators are no longer just supporting the investment thesis; they are increasingly determining whether the investment succeeds or fails." With the median purchase multiple at 11.8x EBITDA in 2025, according to the same report, operating performance has to do the heavy lifting.

Still, the build-out is unfinished. KPMG's survey of 500 PE leaders found a weighted average of 10% of employees in operational value creation roles versus 56% in investment roles, and suggests many firms would need to triple that ratio.

Where the EBITDA leaks

Every handoff is a place where value can slip. The deal team underwrites a number. The operating team inherits it. A specialist turns it into initiatives. An advisor executes some of them. Management is asked to deliver all of it while running the business. Everyone owns a piece. Often, no one owns the whole number.

The results show it. In Alvarez & Marsal's European Private Equity Value Creation Report 2026, 65% of respondents said they had achieved less than half of the value targeted in plans from the past two years. That's despite 58% now deploying value creation resources within the first 100 days, double the year before. The issue isn't speed. It's ownership.

Which operating model actually works?

That leads to the question sponsors debate more than any other. At one end is the individual operating advisor, often a former CEO: real judgment and credibility, but limited reach, and often deployed deal by deal. Morgan Stanley Investment Management argues that putting operating partners on the investment committee and in the carry pool avoids "potential deal-by-deal misalignment."

At the other end are large functional groups: procurement, pricing, talent, and AI centers of excellence. They bring depth and scale, but every function has its own mandate and metrics, and it can end up more focused on that mandate than on the deal. As Lee McCabe, a former operating partner at AEA Investors, wrote in ACG Insights, "companies rarely fail in neat, functional lanes. Instead, they fail in the ugly gaps between them."

In between is every variation. McKinsey has observed that smaller firms tend to favor extended deal teams and larger firms dedicated operating teams, with conflicts arising from "different compensation models or strict distinctions of responsibilities." Here's how the models compare:

  • Individual operating advisor (often ex-CEO). How it typically works: One senior operator per company, often part-time; Strengths: Judgment, credibility with the CEO; Where EBITDA tends to leak: Limited reach; inherits a plan they didn't underwrite; Best fit: Founder-led or growth companies.
  • Extended deal team. How it typically works: Investors with operating backgrounds carry the deal from diligence to execution; Strengths: One team owns the number; Where EBITDA tends to leak: Stretched across new deals; thin functional depth; Best fit: Smaller firms; simpler plans.
  • Dedicated operating team. How it typically works: Larger team takes over after close; Strengths: More hands for execution; Where EBITDA tends to leak: Handoff from deal team; mismatched incentives; Best fit: Larger firms; multi-lever plans.
  • Large functional groups. How it typically works: Portfolio-wide centers of excellence; Strengths: Depth, playbooks, scale; Where EBITDA tends to leak: Functions serve their own mandate; gaps between them; Best fit: Common levers; carve-outs and turnarounds.
  • Hybrid quarterback. How it typically works: Senior operating partner owns the plan; specialists brought in by lever; Strengths: Single owner plus targeted depth; Where EBITDA tends to leak: Breaks down without authority or deal-linked incentives; Best fit: Most sponsors, if designed well.

My view is that the org chart matters less than three design choices underneath it:

  • Is accountability anchored to the deal or to the function? Someone has to own the whole number for this company, not just their slice.
  • Do incentives follow the deal outcome? An operator who shares in the result behaves differently from one measured on programs launched.
  • Does the operator have authority? McCabe describes the classic operating partner as having "influence but no authority. Accountability but no control." Advice without the ability to force a decision is just commentary.

Get those right and a single ex-CEO with carry and real authority can outperform a 40-person functional bench measured on activity, and vice versa.

Closing the accountability gap

Whatever the model, a few practices make the difference:

  • Whoever sizes it, owns it. The person who sized the procurement opportunity in diligence should be answering for it two years later.
  • One name per lever, end to end. Not a committee or a function.
  • Hold advisors to the same standard. Scope work against specific P&L lines and measure EBITDA delivered per dollar of advisory spend.
  • Track it on one page. Underwritten, identified, implemented, and in EBITDA, reviewed monthly at the board.

The industry spent the last five years answering "do we need an operating team?" The answer was yes. The harder question now is who is accountable for making sure the EBITDA we underwrote is the EBITDA we sell.

At your firm, is value creation anchored to the deal or to the function?

David Jadwin is Managing Director and Head of Private Capital at Maine Pointe, where he works with private equity firms, family offices, lenders, and their portfolio companies on supply chain and operations value creation.

Sources

  • McKinsey & Company, "Private equity: Clearer view, tougher terrain" (Global Private Markets Report 2026) (published February 10, 2026)
  • KPMG International, "From stock-pickers to the quant PE house" (KPMG 2025 Global PE Value Creation Survey) (survey of 500 PE leaders, October 2024)
  • Alvarez & Marsal, European Private Equity Value Creation Report 2026 (press release May 19, 2026; Statista Q survey of 200 PE investors and portfolio company executives in 10 European markets, early February 2026)
  • Morgan Stanley Investment Management, "Hands-On Operational Improvement Key to Creating Alpha in the Middle Market" (October 2024; authors Aaron Sack and Patrick Whitehead)
  • Lee McCabe (Claymore Partners), "Why the Operating Partner Model Is Broken," ACG Insights (formerly Middle Market Growth) (June 23, 2026)
  • McKinsey & Company, "From pure investor to entrepreneurial owner: How private-equity firms can master the shift" (September 20, 2019)
David Jadwin, Managing Director, Head of Private Capital
Author
David Jadwin
Managing Director, Head of Private Capital — Maine Pointe
LinkedIn profile ↗
Talk to our team →

Facing this in your business?

Tell us what you're trying to fix. A partner who has done it before will come back to you.

Talk to a partner