Maine PointeResults. Now.™

The Forgotten Lower Middle Market: Why Operational Value Creation Has to Be Rebuilt for $50M–$150M Companies

The operational value creation playbook most of us grew up with was built for big companies.

David Jadwin · Managing Director, Head of Private CapitalLinkedIn profile ↗
5 min read

The operational value creation playbook most of us grew up with was built for big companies. A partner, a manager, four to eight consultants, a multi-month diagnostic, and a fee structure that makes sense when the client has a billion dollars of revenue and a few hundred million of addressable spend.

Now try to drop that model into a $75 million manufacturer with a 10% EBITDA margin. That company generates about $7.5 million of EBITDA a year. A traditional large-firm engagement can eat a meaningful share of that before the first savings hit the P&L. The CEO knows it, the sponsor knows it, and so the work often doesn't happen at all.

That's the gap. And it sits in one of the most important parts of the economy.

Big segment, thin support

According to the National Center for the Middle Market, the U.S. is home to approximately 200,000 middle market companies, defined as businesses with annual revenues between $10 million and $1 billion. They make up about 3% of all U.S. businesses but account for approximately one-third of private-sector GDP and employment.

Private equity is deeply invested in this space. Grant Thornton's Q2 2026 US PE Middle Market Report counted 13,509 active PE-backed portfolio companies in the U.S. as of June 30, 2026. Smaller transactions are where the activity is holding up: deals between $25 million and $100 million generated $16 billion of middle-market value in the quarter, up 70.6% quarter over quarter, and that was the only size band that also grew in deal count.

Those companies are being held longer, too. The same Grant Thornton report found that 3,905 U.S. PE-backed companies, 28.9% of the total, have been held for more than five years. Every extra year of hold puts more pressure on operating performance to carry the return.

The operating support available to these companies hasn't kept pace. Writing about middle-market private equity, Morgan Stanley Investment Management observed that while many sponsors have built some level of operating partner support over the last decade, "these professionals are often external consultants or are deployed on a deal-by-deal basis." That's the core middle market. In my experience, the lower middle market is thinner still: a small fund may have one or two operating partners covering an entire portfolio, if it has any at all.

Why the math favors the small company

The irony is that the lower middle market is where an operational dollar may be worth the most.

Grant Thornton reports that the lower middle market's median EV/EBITDA multiple was 8.5x in Q1 2026, compared with 13.2x for deals between $500 million and $1 billion. Buy a company at 8.5x, take $1.5 million of cost out of procurement, freight, and conversion, and you've created roughly $12.75 million of enterprise value at the entry multiple. If that improvement also helps the business scale into a higher-multiple bracket at exit, the value compounds.

These companies usually have the most obvious opportunities, too. Spend that's never been competitively sourced. Freight booked by habit. Inventory sized by gut feel. A plant that runs well because one supervisor has been there for 22 years. None of that requires a 400-slide diagnostic to find. It requires someone who has seen it before and can fix it.

A smaller format that actually fits

If the big-firm model doesn't scale down, the answer isn't a cheaper version of the same thing. It's a different format. The one I'm building toward has three parts.

One experienced operator. Not a pyramid of junior analysts. One senior person who has run procurement, operations, or a plant, and who can walk in, earn the trust of a founder-led management team, and make decisions alongside them. Lower-middle-market CEOs don't want to be managed by a team of consultants. They want a peer who has done it before.

One forward-deployed engineer. This is the piece that wasn't possible five years ago. A data and AI engineer who works inside the company's own systems, pulling spend data out of the ERP, cleaning it, building the spend cube, standing up the analytics, and putting simple AI agents into the workflows that matter. In a big company that work takes a team. With today's tools, one strong engineer can do the analytical heavy lifting that used to justify a large team, and leave behind something the company keeps using after the engagement ends.

Paid from realized savings. The fee comes out of results, not out of the company's operating budget. Baseline agreed up front. Finance signs off on what counts. The advisor gets paid when the savings show up in the P&L, not when the slides are delivered. That aligns everyone around the same number, and it takes the cash-flow objection off the table for a company that can't write a large check for an uncertain outcome.

What it takes to make it work

This model only works with discipline. Four guardrails matter most.

First, agree on the baseline before anything starts. Savings disputes almost always trace back to a fuzzy baseline. Lock it with the CFO on day one.

Second, focus on a few levers that move cash and margin quickly: direct and indirect procurement, freight and logistics, inventory and working capital, and throughput on the constraint. Leave the five-year transformation roadmap for another day.

Third, build for handoff. The engineer's tools, data models, and agents should belong to the company and be simple enough for the internal team to run. If the value walks out the door when the advisor does, it wasn't value creation.

Fourth, keep the sponsor in the loop without adding a reporting burden. One page, monthly, tied to the value creation plan. Lower-middle-market management teams are thin; every hour spent on reporting is an hour not spent running the business.

An underserved market

Most of the industry's operating playbooks, research, and attention are pointed upmarket. That's understandable; that's where the fees are. But it leaves thousands of PE-backed companies with real EBITDA opportunity and nobody built to capture it at a price that makes sense.

The firms that figure out how to deliver senior operating judgment and modern data capability in a format sized for a $50 million to $150 million company will find a market that has been waiting for them.

If you're a lower-middle-market sponsor, how many companies in your portfolio have never had a real procurement or operations diagnostic, simply because the economics never worked?

David Jadwin is Managing Director and Head of Private Capital at Maine Pointe, where he works with private equity firms, family offices, lenders, and their portfolio companies on supply chain and operations value creation.

Sources

  • National Center for the Middle Market (The Ohio State University), "Middle Market 101"
  • Grant Thornton, "US PE Middle Market Report," Q2 2026
  • Morgan Stanley Investment Management, "Hands-On Operational Improvement Key to Creating Alpha in the Middle Market" (October 2024; authors Aaron Sack and Patrick Whitehead)
David Jadwin, Managing Director, Head of Private Capital
Author
David Jadwin
Managing Director, Head of Private Capital — Maine Pointe
LinkedIn profile ↗
Talk to our team →

Facing this in your business?

Tell us what you're trying to fix. A partner who has done it before will come back to you.

Talk to a partner