Lenders Are Leaving EBITDA on the Table: Why the Supply Chain Is the Most Underused Lever in Private Credit
Private credit has spent the last few years getting very good at one thing: buying time.
Private credit has spent the last few years getting very good at one thing: buying time.
When a borrower gets tight on liquidity, the playbook is well established. Waive the covenant. Amend and extend. Convert cash interest to PIK. Those tools keep good businesses alive through a bad stretch, but none of them generate a dollar of cash or a point of margin. They move the problem down the road. Whether the borrower is in better shape when it gets there depends on what happens inside the operations in the meantime.
And that's the part lenders rarely touch.
The stress is real, and it's mostly being restructured, not fixed
Fitch Ratings reported a U.S. Private Credit Default Rate of 6.3% for the trailing 12 months ended 3Q26, the highest quarterly rate on record. Interest deferrals and PIK introductions made up 50% of default events, maturity extensions under stress 38%, uncured payment defaults 8%, and bankruptcies, liquidations, and out-of-court restructurings just 4%.
In other words, nearly nine in ten default events were renegotiations. The operations didn't get fixed. The loan got rewritten.
Lincoln International's Q3 2026 Private Market Index points the same way. The size-weighted covenant default rate fell to 2.5%, below the six-year average of 3.8%. That sounds healthy. But "bad PIK," introduced after close on loans that didn't have it at origination, was present in 6% of loans, and on those loans loan-to-value had climbed from roughly 45% at close to roughly 75%. As Lincoln's Ron Kahn put it, "the combination of deferred cash interest and deteriorating equity cushions suggests that credit stress may be more pronounced than the 2.5% covenant default rate indicates."
The pressure is concentrated at the smaller end. KBRA's Q3 2026 Middle Market Compendium, covering 3,070 borrowers and more than $1.4 trillion of debt, found lower middle market default rates of 5.8% by both count and debt, versus 3.6% and 2.4% for the full portfolio. About 20% of borrowers reported declining sales, and gross leverage rose for the first time in more than two years.
Covenants measure the outcome; operations drive it
Covenants are lagging indicators. By the time a test trips, the decisions behind it are months old: a supplier price increase accepted rather than negotiated, freight costs drifting up lane by lane, inventory building because planning and purchasing weren't talking, a plant running overtime to cover a bottleneck nobody fixed.
That's where cash and margin are won or lost, and it's fixable, often quickly:
- Working capital. Inventory reduction and payables terms are often the fastest source of cash, frequently within 90 to 180 days, without new money.
- Procurement. Middle-market spend is often under-sourced. Re-sourcing and renegotiation can move margin in weeks, not quarters.
- Logistics and freight. Lane-level rate audits, carrier consolidation, and mode optimization are low-risk and show up directly in COGS.
- Throughput. Fixing the plant constraint cuts overtime, scrap, and expediting, helping both margin and service.
None of this is exotic. It's the toolkit PE operating teams use every day. But a stressed borrower rarely has the bandwidth or specialist expertise to do it alone while managing its lenders. That's where a functional consulting partner, one that lives in procurement, logistics, and operations and is willing to be measured on results, earns its place. In private credit, that option rarely comes up.
Why lenders stay out of it
Lenders have good reasons to keep their distance: lender-liability and control concerns, teams built for underwriting rather than operations, and the view that operations are the sponsor's job.
All fair. But "not our role" now costs real money. Every quarter a stressed borrower spends on PIK without an operational fix, the debt grows and the equity cushion shrinks.
How lenders can step in without overstepping
Lenders don't have to run the business to influence how it's run. These steps keep them in their lane; as always, structure them with counsel.
Make the amendment the trigger. A request for a waiver, extension, or PIK toggle is the moment of maximum alignment. A lender can reasonably condition relief on bringing in an independent functional partner to assess cash and margin, with findings shared with the lender group. The borrower and sponsor own the plan; the lender asks for evidence that one exists and that someone with the right expertise is executing it.
Start with a diagnostic, then move to implementation. A short, fixed-scope assessment of working capital, procurement, logistics, and operations is inexpensive relative to the exposure and shows what's recoverable and how fast. But a report alone doesn't move cash. The value comes when the same partner stays on to implement alongside management: signed supplier
contracts, lower freight rates, a plant that runs without the overtime and expediting, and inventory that actually comes down.
Ask for operational KPIs alongside the financials. Inventory days, purchase price variance, freight cost per unit, overtime as a percent of labor. These move before EBITDA does, giving the lender an early warning covenants can't.
Insist on a results-driven partner. The right partner commits up front to specific outcomes, such as cash released, savings realized, and margin improved, measured against an agreed baseline and reported to the lender group. Results, not activity or slide decks, are what a stressed borrower needs, and they line the partner up with the lender. It also makes the recommendation easy for a sponsor to accept and keeps the lender out of the operating seat.
Bring it to performing borrowers too. This isn't only a workout tool. Introducing a results-driven functional partner as a value-add, or linking an operational review to pricing or flexibility, strengthens the credit, deepens the sponsor relationship, and differentiates the lender in a crowded market.
The opportunity
Private credit is now a core source of middle-market capital, and its outcomes increasingly depend on borrowers' operations. Lenders who pull the operational lever, carefully, within their role, and with a results-driven functional partner, will recover more in stressed situations and build stronger relationships in performing ones.
The covenant tells you something went wrong. The supply chain is usually where you can fix it.
Across your watch list, how many borrowers have had an amendment in the last 18 months, and how many have had a results-driven partner with real functional expertise take a serious look at their working capital, procurement, logistics, and operations?
David Jadwin is Managing Director and Head of Private Capital at Maine Pointe, where he works with private equity firms, family offices, lenders, and their portfolio companies on supply chain and operations value creation.
Sources
- Fitch Ratings, "U.S. Private Credit Default Rate Remains Elevated in 3Q26" (October 29, 2026)
- Lincoln International, "The Lincoln Private Market Index Rises 2.8% in Q3…" (November 2026)
- KBRA, "Private Credit: Q3 2026 Middle Market Compendium: Direct Lending's Smallest Borrowers and Largest Sectors Showing Signs of Stress" (November 5, 2026)
Facing this in your business?
Tell us what you're trying to fix. A partner who has done it before will come back to you.
Talk to a partner



