Maine PointeResults. Now.™

Cost to serve: which customers really make distributors money

Look beyond gross margin before changing customer pricing or service.

Gerald VonFeldt · Senior Advisor, Logistics & DistributionLinkedIn profile ↗
4 min read

The largest account in a branch is not necessarily its best account. Gross margin can look healthy while the warehouse handles fragmented orders and the delivery fleet runs repeated exceptions. Before asking sales to grow the relationship, ask a different question: what does the customer require the network to do, and does the commercial agreement pay for it?

Gross margin is not the destination

A customer can negotiate a respectable product margin and still consume disproportionate operating effort. Frequent small orders, special sourcing, branch transfers, returns and urgent deliveries all draw on people and assets. These demands often sit in branch overhead, far from the account profitability report. Revenue growth can conceal the problem until capacity becomes tight.

Industrial and wholesale distributors should not assume that every costly service pattern is bad business. An emergency delivery may protect a strategic relationship. Technical support may justify a premium elsewhere in the account. The problem is not providing service. It is providing it without knowing what it costs, why it matters or who agreed to it.

The first useful distinction is between product economics and service economics. Preserve the product margin view, then show the activities required to earn it. This avoids asking sales to defend an opaque overhead allocation and gives operations a clearer account of which customer commitments actually drive work.

Use activities the branch can recognize

Begin with observable order and service patterns. Order lines, delivery stops, transfer requests and return inspections are more defensible than allocating warehouse costs by revenue alone. Revenue can increase because prices rise, even when handling effort is unchanged. A meaningful driver should reflect a resource the business actually consumes.

Use a transparent method and acknowledge its limits. Delivery cost depends on route density and time, not just distance. Warehouse effort varies with item size, pick method and handling requirements. Credit administration may be concentrated in particular accounts. Sample actual work where systems do not capture it rather than inventing precise-looking allocations.

  • Connect order lines and shipment records to the customer and serving branch.
  • Identify exceptional work, including expedited sourcing, transfers and special documentation.
  • Separate customer returns from supplier defects and internal fulfillment errors.
  • Review delivery stops, route constraints and failed delivery attempts.
  • Validate the activity picture with branch, sales, finance and operations leaders.

Then distinguish an attributed cost from an avoidable one. If a customer changes delivery frequency, the route may become more efficient without immediately reducing the fleet. That is useful capacity, but it is not automatically a cash saving. Finance should show which benefits depend on consolidating work or changing a resource commitment.

Change the service agreement before the relationship

A poor profitability estimate is a reason to investigate, not an instruction to dismiss a customer. Check whether the account is absorbing internal failures. Repeated split shipments may reflect inaccurate inventory or buying rules rather than unreasonable customer behavior. Charging the customer for that failure would protect the wrong operating model.

Where the service pattern is genuinely customer-driven, offer choices. Scheduled delivery days, consolidated orders, minimum quantities or a separately priced emergency service can preserve availability while improving economics. Explain what the customer gains and what changes. Sales needs a credible alternative to a blunt price increase or a service withdrawal.

Consider network design as well. A branch transfer may be an appropriate exception for a critical part but an expensive routine replenishment method. Total Value Optimization™ (TVO™), connects buying, inventory placement and fulfillment choices. The right intervention may sit in the network rather than in the customer contract.

What to do next: build a usable account review

Start the Distribution Value Assessment with a representative group of accounts and their serving branches. Include different order sizes, delivery patterns and service requirements. Reconcile the activity data to financial totals, but resist implying that every shared expense can be assigned with certainty. Label assumptions that could change the recommendation.

Ask the account owner and branch manager to agree the reason for each costly service pattern. Classify the response as an internal fix, a service redesign, a commercial discussion or an intentional investment. Set decision rights so local teams can retain sensible exceptions without quietly undoing the overall policy.

Track the outcome in both operating and commercial terms. Watch order consolidation, delivery effort, returns and contribution alongside customer retention and buying behavior. If an account becomes cheaper to serve only because it stopped buying profitable products, the intervention failed. The goal is a service model that customers value and the distributor can afford to sustain.

Gerald VonFeldt, Senior Advisor, Logistics & Distribution
Author
Gerald VonFeldt
Senior Advisor, Logistics & Distribution — Maine Pointe
LinkedIn profile ↗
Talk to our team →

Facing this in your business?

Tell us what you're trying to fix. A partner who has done it before will come back to you.

Talk to a partner